I can understand the heart-ache of those whose loved ones have an
unbearable and incurable condition, where the only release is death. We
would not let an animal suffer so; how can we be less humane for humans?
If we can pray that God will end their suffering, can we not allow that
God might want us to be the means by which he answers our prayers?
Although we know that human life is sacred, and that only God has the
right to begin and to end a person's life, yet many Christians say it is
OK for soldiers to kill enemies in a battle.
There is one instance in the Bible of assisted suicide that I can
immediately think of, and it is a disturbing one. In 2 Samuel 1 a man
brings David news of his enemy Saul's death in battle. Saul had tried to
commit suicide to avoid being killed by the Philistines, but was still
alive, so he asked this man to finish him off. He did so, and came to
tell David. But David's reaction was to put him to death:"Why were you
not afraid to destroy the Lord's anointed?... Your blood be on your own
head." (2 Samuel 1:14-16). That always strikes me as being so unfair. I
dare say David maybe had a better idea of fairness and justice than I
have, but it still begs the question, why was that assisted suicide so
wrong in David's eyes?
David had an amazing trust in God's sovereignty over events and over
history. Although he had been anointed king, he refused to lift a finger
to bring that to fulfilment by killing Saul, even when Saul was trying
to kill him and circumstances put Saul in his power. He believed that
only God had the authority to end Saul's life.
Authority may be important in the case of assisted suicide. Should
doctors or loved ones be given authority to end the life of a person in
unbearable and hopeless pain? There are practical and theological
objections to this.
Practically, there is a risk that if such authority is given it will
open the door to dubious cases, when love is not the only motive.
Theologically, authority to end life lies with God, and we take that
authority into our own hands at our peril. God has made it very clear
that human life is sacrosanct, and both murder and suicide are sins
against God. It is a moot point whether assisted suicide is the lesser
of two evils. But I do believe it is better to suffer than to sin against God.
That said, I cannot help but feel for anyone in such a position. If I'd
been the young man seeing Saul in his death throes, I would probably
have helped him on his way and would have expected praise from David.
'You wouldn't let a dog suffer like that.' No, and when our dog suffered
we called for the vet to come and put him down, which he did in our
living room. But it nearly broke my heart. I remember thinking then, 'I
couldn't do that for a human.' But I'd be hammering at the gates of
heaven for God to do something, I'm sure.
If ever the time comes (God forbid) that I have to suffering unbearable pain in my last illness, I pray first, that it won't last too long; and I pray that I will be able to endure it, that I will keep trusting in God's love and perfect care for me, that I will not let him down, and that afterwards I will discover the truth of Paul's saying, 'Our light and momentary troubles are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all.' That is probably easier to pray now than when and if that time comes. And it is not a prayer everyone can pray.